Sure, we knew there were some creative musicians out there who might enter our Neutral Milk Hotel cover song contest. But how could we have expected what musical treasures you, dear readers, sent in?
There was the in-the-red, gleefully distorted version of "Gardenhead/Leave Me Alone" sent in by Ted Farber, and the horn-flavored version of "A Baby for Pree / Where You'll Find Me Now" by Chris Alarie. John Gaby's autotuned "Communist Daughter" changed the time signature to 6/8 with a circus feel, and Brian O'Connor played with chromatics and fretboard slides in a version of "The King of Carrot Flowers, Part II." We even got a crazy cut-and-paste edit called "Two-Headed Sex Machine Man" from Ricardo M'ohaire that chopped together samples of James Brown, Neutral Milk Hotel and various spoken-word recordings.
But when it came time to select a winner, we went with Dustin Heald's imaginative cover of "You've Passed," played on guitar, darbuka, zils and melodica. Without trying to emulate the letter of Mangum's delivery, the version captures the slight Middle Eastern spirit of the intro lick and takes the song to another place entirely. Congratulations, Dustin, you've won two tickets to Jeff Mangum's sold-out show at the Phoenix Theater on Tuesday, April 9.
Hear Dustin's winning cover song here.
Thanks to everyone who sent in their songs!