- LIKE OIL AND WATER U.S. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke exempted Florida from offshore-drilling plans. Why not California?
Last week, Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom was one of numerous elected officials from around the nation to tee off on U.S. Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke for his decision to exempt offshore drilling in the vacation state of Florida while failing to do the same for blue states such as California with big tourist economies of their own.
The move by Zinke highlighted a federal energy policy under President Donald Trump to open offshore drilling, but only if it doesn't interfere with Trump's ocean view from Mar-a-Lago.
Newsom zeroed-in his critique, via a few pointed tweets directed at Zinke, over the secretary's rationale for giving Florida a pass from fulfilling the Trump administration's offshore-drilling plans as detailed in a report released this month from the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM), which operates under the aegis of the Department of the Interior.
Newsom noted that Zinke cited the impact on the state's tourism industry as the signal driver behind his decision to keep the drilling rigs from view of tourists. Zinke did not, however, extend the same courtesy to other states with a robust tourist economy: Oregon, New York, Virginia and, of course, California.
Newsom had the numbers on hand to make his point. Florida, he noted in a series of tweets directed at Zinke, had 113 million visitors in 2016, while California had 269 million statewide visitor trips. Tourists in Florida spent $109 billion; in California, they spent $126.3 billion.
"Using this logic," tweeted Newsom, "CA's coast should be declared free of offshore drilling as well. Or do blue states not get exemptions?"
So far, they do not, and Newsom was unavailable for further comment on the matter. The BOEM document, the 2019-2024 proposed draft for the National Outer Continental Oil Shelf and Gas Leasing Program (the OCS, for short), sets out a Trump-approved schedule for renewed offshore drilling from the North Atlantic around the bend of the Gulf of Mexico, and up to Northern California and the Pacific Northwest.
Under the OCS, the federal government will sell drilling leases in Northern California in 2021, and then again in 2023. The feds would offer new lease sales in Southern California in 2020 and 2022. Central California would also see new potential leases in 2021 and 2023.
The last offshore drilling leases in Northern California were sold in 1963, when seven exploratory wells were drilled and came up dry. That same year, a dozen exploratory wells were drilled in Central California and, similarly, no oil was found. Oil was discovered in Southern California, which is where all the current leases are.
The idea is that this time around, improvements in oil-exploration technology may yield something other than mud. The problem is those improvements are causing grave concern among opponents—a concern now met with outrage over the Zinke duplicity in Florida.
"Offshore drilling is inherently dangerous," says Kristen Monsell, a senior attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity. The Oakland-based Monsell notes that the practice "causes dangerous pollution, risks devastating oil spills that kill marine life and harm coastal communities, and exacerbates the climate crisis."
The advent of offshore fracking, which would be allowed by the Trump administration's plan, "only heightens those risks," she says. That process involves blasting a high-pressure water-and-chemical stew into the ocean floor, which cracks rocks and exposes oil or gas fields.
"The high pressures used in offshore fracking increase the risk of well failure and oil spills."
Then there's the back end, says Monsell. Federal rules allow petrochemical companies to "dump their waste fluids, including fracking chemicals, into the ocean," she says. "Scientists have identified some commonly used fracking chemicals to be among the most toxic in the world to aquatic life."
Her organization is pushing to end all offshore drilling and vows to fight the Trump move in court. "We need to transition away from this dirty, dangerous practice and toward a clean-energy future."